Driving while intoxicated (DWI) checkpoints, also known as sobriety checkpoints, have been the subject of much discussion over their legitimacy and effectiveness in improving public safety. While checkpoints are allowed in several states, the police must follow strict protocols for their operation. Law enforcement must follow certain criteria to avoid violating citizens' constitutional rights.
The legality of a DWI checkpoint does not mean that your rights cannot be violated during the process. An experienced DWI lawyer can assess the circumstances surrounding your arrest and ensure that your rights are protected throughout the legal proceedings.
Schedule Your Free Consultation
Legal Frameworks and Constitutional Considerations
In Michigan Department of State Police v. Sitz, the Supreme Court ruled that DWI checkpoints are constitutional. The Court decided that, while checkpoints are a "seizure" under the Fourth Amendment, they’re still acceptable if set up correctly and serve the public good. The Court decided that the state's interest in preventing drunk driving exceeded the minor intrusion on individual liberty that brief checkpoint stops may cause.
However, this decision came with some significant caveats. Law enforcement must adhere to strict rules to ensure checkpoints are constitutional and do not infringe on citizens' rights. These requirements establish a framework that balances public safety and individual freedoms.
Key Requirements for Legal DWI Checkpoints
The following requirements for setting up sobriety checkpoints ensure that drivers encountering road stops are not subject to issues that interfere with their privacy.
Advance Public Notice
One of the most basic needs for a legal DWI checkpoint is advance notification to the public. Law enforcement organizations must notify the public about planned checkpoints using various channels, including local media, social media platforms, and official department websites. While they are not required to reveal the actual site, they must provide basic information on when and where checkpoints may occur.
Predetermined Written Policy
Police departments must create and adhere to a written policy that specifies the checkpoint's methods, purpose, and operational details. This documentation should include precise standards for officer conduct, criteria for stopping cars, and procedures for dealing with various scenarios that may emerge during the operation.
Random Selection Process
A critical component of constitutional DWI checkpoints is the requirement for random vehicle selection. Law enforcement cannot target certain vehicle kinds, demographics, or persons. The predefined strategy must provide a neutral formula for halting vehicles, such as stopping every third vehicle or all vehicles passing through the checkpoint.
Strategic Location Selection.
Police should carefully select DWI checkpoints using objective criteria. Checkpoints should not be regularly placed at the same site, as this may constitute harassment of specific populations. Instead, law enforcement should choose sites based on variables like:
- The history of DWI events in the area
- Traffic patterns and volume
- Safety concerns for both officers and motorists
- Adequate space for safely executing checkpoint operations
- The ability to provide a clear view and warning to oncoming cars
The above checklist enables law officers to operate checkpoints safely and efficiently.
Valid Public Interest Purpose
Each checkpoint must have a reasonable public safety purpose. While DWI enforcement is usually the primary purpose, checkpoints can also address other legitimate public safety concerns. Those concerns include reviewing legal licenses and registration.
What Happens at a DWI Checkpoint?
Understanding the standard procedure at a DWI checkpoint will assist drivers in anticipating what to expect and how to express their rights while complying with proper legal procedures. One of the key benefits of hiring a DWI lawyer is their in-depth knowledge of the laws and procedures related to DWI offenses.
Initial Contact
When motorists approach a checkpoint, they usually notice warning signs, lights, and uniformed officials. Officers will typically ask to see the driver's license and car registration. During the initial interaction, officers look for indicators of impairment, such as:
- The smell of alcohol
- Slurred speech.
- Red or glassy eyes
- Confused answers to basic questions
- Visible open containers or other signs of alcohol use
The above list of indicators allows law enforcement to move on to the next step in the process.
Basic Screening Process
Officers will briefly delay most drivers who show no impairment before allowing them to continue. If an officer observes possible symptoms of impairment, they may direct the driver to a secondary screening location for further inspection.
Secondary Screening
Law enforcement officers may ask drivers to submit to a secondary screening. This secondary screening includes undertaking field sobriety tests or preliminary breath tests. This more extensive inquiry takes place apart from the main checkpoint flow to ensure efficiency and safety.
Your Rights at DWI Checkpoints
Drivers must halt at legal checkpoints. However, law enforcement should respect their constitutional rights throughout the interaction.
The Right to Remain Silent
Aside from giving essential identity and vehicle paperwork, drivers have the right to remain silent. Motorists are not obligated to answer inquiries about where they have been, where they are going, or if they have consumed alcohol.
Refusal of Consent
Drivers might decline to allow a search of their car. However, if officers find probable cause during the stop, they may perform a search without consent.
Documentation Rights
Drivers have the right to record the checkpoint encounter on video or audio as long as it does not interfere with police operations.
Professional Conduct
When asserting these rights, it is critical to maintain courtesy and professionalism. Being aggressive or belligerent is rarely beneficial and may worsen the situation.
Avoiding DWI Checkpoints
Be careful while you can bypass a DWI checkpoint by doing a legal turn before approaching it.
Law enforcement officers frequently look for vehicles making rapid or illegal turns to evade the checkpoint site. Such evasive activities may raise reasonable suspicion about the roadblock.
Common Questions Regarding DWI Checkpoints
Below are questions drivers typically ask concerning DWI checkpoints.
Can I turn around?
Yes, but only if doing so is legal and safe. An unlawful U-turn or other driving infringement to evade a checkpoint may result in a traffic stop.
Should I roll down my window?
You must roll your window down enough to talk with officials and present the needed documentation, but you are not fully required.
Can I refuse a Breathalyzer Test?
While you have the right to decline a preliminary breath test at the checkpoint, doing so may result in detention for an additional examination if you show symptoms of impairment. Furthermore, under implied consent legislation, declining a formal breath test on arrest can lead to an immediate license suspension.
Arrested at a DWI Checkpoint? Contact a DWI Attorney for Best Results
DWI checkpoints are lawful and extensively used in law enforcement's fight against intoxicated driving. While they are considered a brief seizure under the Fourth Amendment, courts have routinely maintained the validity of the roadblock.
Contact a DWI lawyer if officers arrest you at a checkpoint. Remember, being arrested at a DWI checkpoint can be a frightening and overwhelming experience. By contacting a skilled DWI attorney, you can gain peace of mind knowing that you have an advocate on your side. Talk to a Carteret County criminal defense attorney if authorities arrest you for DWI.